Rating

Our average rating: 4.3 from 145 reviews

  • Food 4.3/5
  • Quantity 4.2/5
  • Service 4.2/5

Reviewed by Dawn

on Jan 27, 2012 08:48 AM -06:00

I never received the mashed potatoes even though we were charged for it.


  • Classics - Beefsteak  Love It
  • Classics - Horseradish Beef  Love It
  • Wraps - Southwest Veggie  Love It
  • Grinders - Parmesan Tuna Grinder  Love It
  • Sides - Small Chipotle Mac & Cheese  Love It
  • The Birds - Pepper Turkey  Love It
  • Wraps - Monterey Chicken  Love It
  • Chili and More... - Small Northwoods Chili  Love It
  • Chili and More... - Small Soup of the Day  Love It
  • Sides - Small Mashed Potatoes  Hate It

Average rating: 4.0

  • Food 4/5
  • Quantity 4/5
  • Service 4/5

Reviewed by Christine

on Dec 30, 2011 04:33 PM -06:00

Subpocalypse = best sandwich ever!


  • Costello’s “Baked Is Better” Icons - Subpocalypse  Love It
  • Kids Menu - Kids Cheese Pizza Boat  Love It
  • Soda & Water - Diet Coke  Love It
  • Chili and More... - Medium Chili Mac  Love It

Average rating: 5.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Nicholas

on Dec 12, 2011 07:36 AM -06:00

Lots of hot delicious food. Sides are great.


Average rating: 5.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Brian

on Nov 20, 2011 10:21 PM -06:00

Delivery was fast!


Average rating: 5.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Tom

on Nov 13, 2011 01:45 PM -06:00

Very fast delivery. Food was excellent. Only criticism was on the Southern Reuben. The bread would have been better toasted. Meatball sub was delicious.


  • Classics - Italian Meatball  Love It
  • Costello’s “Baked Is Better” Icons - Southern Reuben  Love It

Average rating: 4.3

  • Food 4/5
  • Quantity 4/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by John

on Sep 05, 2011 08:52 PM -05:00

In my prior call in order something was forgotten. When I went to pick up this order it seemed light so I asked, "Are the drinks in the bag?" Response – "everything is in the bag" . I thought I would check anyway when I got in my car and the two bottles of root beer were missing.
I went in and the person apologized and gave me the drinks.
I give the 20% tip so workers are encouraged to get the order correct.


Average rating: 3.3

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 4/5
  • Service 1/5

Reviewed by Kathy

on Aug 23, 2011 07:52 PM -05:00

Using a charge card and adding the tip is a good idea.


Average rating: 5.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Alicia

on Aug 23, 2011 12:37 PM -05:00

Your site moved a bit slow, but I knew the order would be completed before the time it stated. I went early and my order was waiting. It might have been cold had I waited as long as Zup stated.


Average rating: 4.7

  • Food 4/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Meghan

on Jan 23, 2012 07:49 PM -06:00


  • Chili and More... - Large Pizza Bread  Hate It
  • Soda & Water - Sprecher Root Beer  Love It
  • Soda & Water - Bottled Water  Love It
  • Desserts - Chocolate Chip Giant Cookie  Love It
  • The Birds - Turkey Lite  Love It

Average rating: 5.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Nicole

on Dec 13, 2011 02:45 PM -06:00


  • Grinders - Italian Grinder  Love It
  • Classics - Horseradish Beef  Love It
  • Wraps - Turkey & Muenster  Love It

Average rating: 5.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Nicholas

on Dec 12, 2011 07:35 AM -06:00


  • Classics - Classics Meal  Love It
  • Chili and More... - Large Chili Mac  Love It

Average rating: 5.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Nick

on Dec 06, 2011 05:40 PM -06:00


  • Free Giant Cookie Special - Free Giant Cookie - My Free Giant Cookie  Love It
  • Costello’s “Baked Is Better” Icons - The Mess  Love It
  • Focaccia - Pesto Chicken  Love It
  • Classics - Tavern Ham & Swiss  Love It

Average rating: 4.3

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 4/5
  • Service 4/5

Reviewed by Andrew

on Dec 01, 2011 08:06 AM -06:00


  • Costello’s “Baked Is Better” Icons - Southern Reuben  Love It
  • Chili and More... - Large Cheesy Garlic Bread  Love It
  • Soda & Water - Sprecher Root Beer  Love It

Average rating: 5.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Ryan

on Nov 21, 2011 08:20 AM -06:00


  • Wraps - Parmesan Tuna Wrap  Love It
  • Chili and More... - Medium Chili Mac  Love It
  • Costello’s “Baked Is Better” Icons - Subpocalypse  Love It

Average rating: 4.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 2/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Eric

on Nov 14, 2011 03:13 PM -06:00


  • Classics - Classics Meal  Love It
  • Costello’s “Baked Is Better” Icons - Costello’s Icons Sandwich Meal  Love It

Average rating: 5.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Melissa

on Nov 12, 2011 05:25 PM -06:00


  • Costello’s “Baked Is Better” Icons - Spicy Roscoe  Love It

Average rating: 4.7

  • Food 4/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Kim

on Oct 29, 2011 12:28 PM -05:00


Average rating: 4.0

  • Food 4/5
  • Quantity 4/5
  • Service 4/5

Reviewed by lole

on Oct 29, 2011 12:22 PM -05:00


Average rating: 5.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Tiffany

on Oct 24, 2011 08:59 AM -05:00


Average rating: 5.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Lee

on Oct 11, 2011 08:11 AM -05:00


Average rating: 4.3

  • Food 4/5
  • Quantity 4/5
  • Service 5/5

 
FEEDBACK