Rating

Our average rating: 4.4 from 165 reviews

  • Food 4.4/5
  • Quantity 4.4/5
  • Service 4.3/5

Reviewed by Alissa

on May 07, 2012 06:41 AM -05:00

would be nice if you were notified when you’re order left the store.


  • Free Giant Cookie Special - Free Giant Cookie - My Free Giant Cookie  Love It
  • The Birds - Chipotle Chicken  Love It
  • Grinders - Turkey & Provolone Grinder  Love It
  • Sides - Medium Chipotle Mac & Cheese  Love It

Average rating: 4.0

  • Food 4/5
  • Quantity 4/5
  • Service 4/5

Reviewed by Julie

on May 02, 2012 11:07 AM -05:00

Costello’s is always the best! Love their sandwiches!


  • Classics - Italian Meatball  Love It

Average rating: 5.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Julie

on Apr 26, 2012 09:34 AM -05:00

The meatball sub was a very large portion — I got 2 meals out of it! The meatballs were really good and the sauce and cheese were great toppings. I love ordering from Costello’s. The delivery is pretty fast and they have a great selection of sandwiches and salads.


Average rating: 5.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Julie

on Apr 26, 2012 09:33 AM -05:00


  • Classics - Italian Meatball  Love It

Average rating: 5.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Chris

on Apr 24, 2012 06:02 PM -05:00

This order was delivered super-fast. The staff and delivery people are always nice. The one complaint I have is that they aren’t good about "hold tomatoes" and other customizations like that. Sometimes they do it, but more often they miss it or go 1 for 2 on our sandwiches. Beyond that, they’re great and good value also.


  • The Birds - Pepper Turkey  Love It
  • Grinders - Turkey & Provolone Grinder  Love It
  • Arizona Teas - Green Tea  Love It

Average rating: 4.0

  • Food 4/5
  • Quantity 4/5
  • Service 4/5

Reviewed by Jenny

on Apr 21, 2012 03:08 PM -05:00

Took 2 hours, food was cold, and service was less than apologetic.


  • Kid's Menu - Kids Cheese Pizza Boat  Hate It
  • Costello’s “Baked Is Better” Icons - Southern Reuben  Hate It

Average rating: 1.7

  • Food 1/5
  • Quantity 3/5
  • Service 1/5

Reviewed by Ellen

on Mar 30, 2012 08:04 AM -05:00


  • The Birds - Pepper Turkey  Love It
  • Grinders - Turkey & Provolone Grinder  Love It

Average rating: 4.7

  • Food 4/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Jennifer

on Mar 26, 2012 09:23 AM -05:00

The smoked turkey was kind of gross… had a texture reminiscent of bologna. But I am very picky about meat. Everything else was great.


  • The Birds - The Birds Meal  Hate It

Average rating: 4.0

  • Food 2/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Katherine

on Mar 16, 2012 06:10 PM -05:00


  • Grinders - Grinders Meal  Love It
  • The Birds - The Birds Meal  Love It

Average rating: 5.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

Reviewed by Laurie

on Feb 26, 2012 01:22 PM -06:00


  • Costello’s “Baked Is Better” Icons - Subpocalypse  Love It
  • Costello’s “Baked Is Better” Icons - The Mess  Love It
  • Chili and More... - Medium Northwoods Chili  Love It
  • Desserts - Roscoe Cluster Giant Cookie  Love It
  • Soda & Water - Coke  Love It
  • Soda & Water - Sprecher Cream Soda  Love It

Average rating: 5.0

  • Food 5/5
  • Quantity 5/5
  • Service 5/5

 
FEEDBACK